State Library of Victoria \ Inside a dog
Skip to main content

What film adaptations are you looking forward to?

Oct 23,2012
Printer-friendly versionSend to friend
How I Live Now

Why is it we book fans are so obsessed with film adaptations of our favourite stories?

No matter how brilliant or popular a book, it’s not considered to have ‘made it’ until it’s been turned into a film or TV series.

That’s certainly true from a financial perspective for most writers (blockbuster authors aside), but a film or TV adaptation isn’t necessarily a reflection on the quality of the source material.

And yet, we get so excited when a story we love is going to be filmed. Maybe it’s because we want to experience it in as many ways as possible. Maybe it’s because we want to see if a filmmaker sees the story the same way we do. Maybe we just like re-living the story in 120 minutes.

One of the upcoming film adaptations I’m most interested in is Meg Rosoff’s ‘How I Live Now’ (yes, Inky, I forgot to add that one to my ‘favourites’ list earlier in the week). I loved the story, and want to see if filmmakers can capture the beauty and power of Daisy’s story. This one is a bit tougher than say, 'Twilight', because it sits more on the literary side of the fence.

Paranormal, fantasy and romance stories tend to lend themselves more to film/TV than literary fiction because they are generally quite visual to start with. (The arguments about what is and isn't literary fiction applies in this context as well.)

File 11625I’m curious to see the upcoming adaptation of Stephenie Meyer’s ‘The Host’ (which, like ‘How I Live Now’, stars Saoirse Ronan and is out next year). I thought Meyer put an original twist on the old body-snatchers theme and I suspect the story will work even better on the big screen.

Here's the current trailer.

Lots of books are optioned by filmmakers (which means a production company has bought the rights to make a film or TV series), but not all get ‘green lit’ (going into actual production).

A couple of my favourite books have been optioned but not yet progressed, including Maggie Stiefvater’s ‘Shiver’ and ‘The Scorpio Races’ (and, if rumour is to be believed, ‘The Raven Boys’). (Laini Taylor’s ‘Daughter of Smoke and Bone’ has also been optioned as has Lauren Kate’s ‘Fallen’.)

File 11630There’s definitely a rush on the big YA titles at the moment: Veronica Roth’s ‘Divergent’ (2014) has been green lit (casting is under way), as is Cassandra Clare’s ‘Mortal Instrument’s: City of Bones’, due out in 2013.

Next up, though, is the wonderfully gothic ‘Beautiful Creatures’ (by Kami Garcia and Margaret Stohl), out early next year, and of course there’s ‘Breaking Dawn: Part 2’ in the meantime in November.

So, what film/TV adaptation are you excited about? What have been your favourites in recent years?

(PS: Congrats to the Inky winners!)

Nov 01,2012
Julia: You make some good points. :) Each book should be judged on its own merits, as should any films adapted from them. I definitely agree that films do often encourage more people to read the original book, so that's a good thing! And yes, there are thousands (if not hundreds of thousands) of wonderful books out there that may never make it to the big or small screen, and that's no reflection on their quality!
Oct 31,2012
In my view I don't think that it is necessarily for a book to be made into a film to make it because I have read and enjoyed many books that haven't been made into films or TV series and I have enjoyed them immensely. To think that some people think that a good movie equals a good book is a little sad because i have seen some bad movies that also have a book and I must say that the book is usually quite good even if the movie isn't. There are plenty of books that have gone big and don’t have movies or TV series about them and there are also books that have been made into movies and TV series that haven’t made it big at all. I think that it's quite sad that some people base their thoughts about some books just on movies and not on the actual book. Though I must admit sometimes movies coming out do encourage us to read the book.
Oct 31,2012
I agree that it's very hard for any filmmaker to meet a readers' expectation - especially it's a story/characters you really connect with. And it's certainly possible that books can become successful without movies (although Hollywood won't stay away too long if there's money to be made).
Oct 30,2012
I agree with what she has to say about books only being a success if they have become a film or TV show. I think it is important that it is translated to meet our expectations.
Oct 30,2012
anonymous's picture
Anonymous
i actually prefer the book, because no matter how hard they try they cant do the book justice when it gets made into a movie. i feel with a book its more enjoyable and gives your imagination a work out and you can imagine the characters and really be there in the story. this is just my opinion :)
Oct 30,2012
Gemma: Yes, you're right. There have been plenty of less-than-stellar book adaptations. And as a fan of the original book, it can be very frustrating - especially if people who haven't read the book judge it by the dodgy TV/film.
Oct 29,2012
I dont necessarily thik that a movie has made it if it has been turn into a movie or tv series because there are plenty of books that have made it that arent movies or tv series. Also some books are made into tv series or movies but not all make it big.
Oct 29,2012
Cookie_Love: I haven't read the James Patterson series. I'm assuming it's got plenty of action? And the whole anime (and graphic novel) option is interesting for books. But I agree, it's not quite the same as a live action film...
Oct 28,2012
I can;t wait for a film adaptation of the first Maximum Ride novel (James Patterson). I have to wait till late 2013 though. :O I also wish Deltora Quest had been amde into a movie or at least a decent TV series, not a anime series. No offence meant to anime fans!
Oct 25,2012
anonymous's picture
Anonymous
I'm with you especially with the Hunger Games. I was so excited when it came out and couldn't wait to see the movie after reading the book, LOVED IT!! When I was finally able to watch it I was totally disappointed. They left out so much inner thoughts of the characters that you don't see on screen that can only be expressed through reading.
Oct 24,2012
Nicole: Yes, I know. How I Live Now could go either way. It does bode well that Saoirse Ronan is in it (agree totally with Ambivalence that she's awesome. :) Bryana: Harry Potter is such an interesting one because each film is an individual adaptation of the relevant book, rather than flowing on from the film before. Because there have been different directors and different writers - and so much material to work from with each book - each film has focused on different elements of the story. Those of us who have read all the books can fill in the gaps, but I have no idea how anyone who has only seen the films can appreciate the story in all its multi-layered splendor. (Or, for that matter, not get confused from time to time about what's going on!) Ambivalence: The book is always enough for me too, and then any excitement/curiosity about a film tends to only build once one has been announced. Having said that, most best-selling YA author blogs usually field regularly questions about 'when is a movie going to be made' so it's certainly on a lot of readers' radars. (BTW: I still prefer THG book over the film.)
Oct 24,2012
How I Live Now!!!! I am both excited and dreading it. Purely because I loved the book beyond anything.
Oct 23,2012
In the past I was excited about Harry Potter. I began reading the series when I was in Grade prep and mum, my sister and I would read it all together. When we heard it was going to become a movie, I think the reason we got excited was because we could experience it differently and actually set images in our head, and give us a clearer understanding.
Oct 23,2012
I disagree! I'm usually very satisfied with a book by itself. Before it was decided that THG would become a movie, I had already decided that the book by itself was safer because everything was perfect in imagination, and they would never capture it as perfectly as in our heads. Only when it was known that it was becoming a movie did we - my friends and I - get excited. So that I have to agree with. When it's announced, I always find myself getting hyped up, because yeah, it's fun to experience it in different mediums, as you say (: I liked The Host, not so much for a movie, but I'm excited because Saoirse Ronan is in it. She's awesome. I think she did a fabulous job with The Lovely Bones x)

Post new Comment

All comments are moderated and will not appear immediately. Please be patient - we're keen to know what you think and will get to your comment as fast as we can.